Skip to content

Do You Really Trust Your SEO Company? 5 Red Flags to Look Out For

Having a team of SEO experts assisting you with your site’s SEO campaign is often the best way to go. You don’t have to do everything yourself and can instead rely on SEO specialists to optimise your site for SEO purposes. I said ‘often’ because, unfortunately, there are some shady SEO companies out there. Even…
Reading Time: 3 minutes

Having a team of SEO experts assisting you with your site’s SEO campaign is often the best way to go. You don’t have to do everything yourself and can instead rely on SEO specialists to optimise your site for SEO purposes. I said ‘often’ because, unfortunately, there are some shady SEO companies out there. Even worse, working with bad SEO companies can harm your site’s search engine rankings.

Do you really trust your SEO company? How can you tell if the service provider you use is doing his job properly? Here are the top five red flags to spot.

[siteorigin_widget class=”WP_Widget_Media_Image”][/siteorigin_widget]

1. Mysterious Link Placement

One of the first red flags you can spot easily is the SEO company’s unwillingness to share the locations of your backlinks. Quality backlinks are handy for boosting SEO performance, but bad ones will either have no effect on your ranking, or lead to a penalty. In fact, even after the recent Google Penguin 4.0 update in which poor links were devalued as opposed to leading to penalties, Google have stated that websites which seem to be purposely scamming search can still have manual penalties applied.

A good service provider will always provide a report on backlinks they generate for your site. You can also check to see whether the backlinks are delivering human traffic to further assess the quality of the SEO company.

2. Unreadable Articles

Whether it is a guest post, a paid placement or any other type of off-site SEO, having an unreadable article written specifically for SEO is never a good thing. Again, this goes against the way today’s search engines rank websites.

The focus of search engines today is quality, not quantity. Terms like keyword density are no longer important. What’s important is user experience upon reading the article. If the articles posted to generate backlinks are not readable, you’re most likely dealing with a bad SEO company.

3. Lack of User Engagement

The next metric you can check is user engagement. A high bounce rate and low time-on-site are often signs of a bad website, but they can also be used to measure whether the traffic your site gets is actually human traffic that interacts with the site.

Don’t forget that user engagement is more important than ever because it is among the signals used by search engines to measure the quality of your site. Low user engagement usually means bad SEO practices.

4. SEO and SEO Only

It is nearly impossible to use SEO as the only internet marketing instrument for promoting a site. Content marketing, social media campaigns and various other tools must be used in conjunction for a good SEO campaign.

An SEO company that doesn’t look at the bigger picture is not going to help your site. One that is reluctant to integrate the SEO campaign with other internet marketing tools is even worse.

5. Promises and Quick Turnarounds

Even with the most recent updates on search engine algorithms – promising real-time response to on- and off-site changes – it is still impossible to do SEO overnight. It is also impossible to guarantee that your site will rank in a certain way for a predetermined period of time. When an SEO company makes high promises and promises a turnaround time that’s too quick, you have reasons to suspect the company’s capabilities.

Spot these red flags and you won’t have to worry about running into problems, or suffering from penalties, in the future. With a good team of SEO specialists at your side, promoting your website and gaining a lot of targeted traffic are indeed very easy to do.

James Owen, Co-Founder & Head Of Search

James has been involved in SEO and digital marketing projects since 2007. James has led many SEO projects for well-known brands in Travel, Gaming and Retail such as Jackpotjoy, Marriott, Intercontinental Hotels, Hotels.com, Expedia, Betway, Gumtree, 888, Ax Paris, Ebyuer, Ebay, Hotels combined, Smyths toys, love honey and Pearson to name a few. James has also been a speaker at SEO and digital marketing conferences and events such as Brighton SEO.

View all Downloads

Downloads

eBook: SEO Strategy for 2023

SEO Strategy for 2023

Without the correct tactics, your website doesn’t have a chance of appearing prominently on search engine results pages. Because if…

Download

Digital Marketing for 2022: The Complete Roundup

If Google's latest Web Core Vitals update has caused havoc to your SEO results, find your solution in our latest in-depth ebook.

Download
Ebook: Ultimate Guide To Enterprise SEO

Ultimate Guide To Enterprise SEO

While the fundamentals of SEO remain the same no matter the size of your business, if you are an enterprise…

Download
View the Blog

You may also be interested in...

Why Personas Are Essential for Modern SEO and AI-Driven Search

For years, SEO has been driven by a relatively simple formula: identify the right keywords,…

How AI Search Is Presenting Your Brand (And How Click Insights Helps You Track It)

The introduction of the internet forever changed how brands experienced visibility, and, with its updates…

How Content Hubs and Entity Clusters Drive AI SEO Performance

Search is getting smarter by the day, and the way we create content needs to…

From Search Engines to AI Engines: Choosing SEO That Performs Everywhere

For years, success equated to being highly ranked in Google’s organic search results, but the…

Editorial Links: Why They Matter for AI SEO

When it comes to succeeding with modern SEO, there are many avenues to explore, but…

Google March 2026 Spam Update: What It Means for Your SEO Strategy

On March 24, 2026, Google announced that it was rolling out its latest spam update…

How to Get LLMs to Mention Your Brand

Simply appearing on a search page isn’t enough anymore, not in today’s world driven by…

Follow vs. Nofollow: Why Your AI Search Strategy Needs Both to Succeed

Follow vs nofollow links have been debated in digital marketing for years. Questions are often…

View all Guides

Online Guides

Best PR Link Building Agencies
View guide
Best UK PR Link Building Agencies
View guide
Best UK Brand Mentions Agencies
View guide
The Ultimate SEO & AI Search Strategy Guide for Car Dealers
View guide
Brand Mentions SEO & AI Search Strategy Guide
View guide
The Ultimate Backlinking Strategy Guide
View guide
Manual Outreach SEO & AI Search Strategy Guide
View guide
10 Best US Consulting Agencies
View guide
Back To Top